Essentials

Meta

Pages

Categories

  • I’m falling asleep

  • UserOnline

  • RSS Feedburner

    • North Korea rocket breaks up soon after launch
      North Korea’s long-range rocket failed early Friday, U.S. officials said. The rocket broke up soon after taking off. “All indications are that it failed,” one official said but went on to say that they are still looking into it. The White House said it would issue a statement, NBC News reported. The launch, which North Korea’s neighbors […]
    • North Korea launches long-range missile
      North Korea launched a long-range rocket early Friday, U.S. officials confirmed. The White House said it would issue a statement, NBC News reported. The launch, which North Korea’s neighbors and the West say is a disguised ballistic missile test, will take a three-stage rocket over a sea separating the Korean peninsula from China before releasing […]
  • Technorati
  • Worlds most simple website

  • Recent Comments

  • Stuff

  • RSS BBC-Business

    • Yahoo jumps on Alibaba deal talk May 18, 2012
      Shares in internet giant Yahoo rise 5% on reports that it is close to selling its valuable stake in Alibaba Group, the Chinese e-commerce company. […]
    • Facebook shares spike on debut May 18, 2012
      Facebook shares are trading flat at $38 on their stock market debut, having initially jumped to $42 within minutes of trade beginning. […]
    • LSE reveals strong profits rise May 18, 2012
      The London Stock Exchange bucks the economic turmoil to deliver a better-than-expected rise in annual profit. […]
    • VIDEO: EU 'taking all neccessary action' May 18, 2012
      EU Economic Commissioner Olli Rehn has said the eurozone is taking "all neccessary action in order to overcome" the debt crisis. […]
    • Euro fears on the streets of Spain May 18, 2012
      Spain, feeling fragile, looks to Germany for help […]
    • Market jitters over eurozone woes May 18, 2012
      European markets suffer a nervous session with investors unsettled by a downgrade for Spanish banks and the political crisis in Greece. […]
    • Ticketus contract 'terminated' May 18, 2012
      Charles Green says administrators at Rangers have told Ticketus they are terminating its contract over future ticket sales. […]
    • EU 'plans for Greek exit option' May 18, 2012
      The EU Commission and European Central Bank are making contingency plans for a possible Greek exit from the euro, an EU commissioner says. […]
    • VIDEO: From prison to Belfast distillery May 18, 2012
      A notorious Belfast prison that held IRA inmates during the worst of the city's sectarian troubles is to be transformed into a whiskey distillery. […]
    • JP Morgan boss to testify in US May 18, 2012
      JP Morgan chairman and chief executive Jamie Dimon will appear before a Senate committee to explain the bank's $2bn trading loss on a failed hedging strategy. […]

Bush: Foot In Mouth

President George W. Bush is at it again. During a Thursday press conference in Washington, our brain-locked leader uttered the following in an attempt to defend his 2003 invasion of Iraq. Appearantly, we were forced to act because no leader could emerge to stop the  sectarian bloodshead:

“I heard somebody say, ‘Where’s Mandela?’ Well, Mandela’s dead because Saddam Hussein killed all the Mandelas.”

Nelson Mandela, 89, South Africa’s first black president and a Nobel Peace Prize winner, is still very much alive.

Comment Pages

There are 24 Comments to "Bush: Foot In Mouth"

  • Bryan says:

    Serious question (one I hope you’ll answer):

    Where do you think Bush got the idea that Saddam Hussein killed Nelson Mandela?

  • Bryan says:

    (along with any clones of Nelson Mandela, apparently, since Bush seems to think that Hussein killed every single one of him).

  • Manfred says:

    I can only assume that he was speaking rhetorically, as in “Saddam killed liberty,” but with Bush, it’s hard to be sure.
    And remember, GWB hates the idea of cloning, going so far as stonewalling stem cell research to insure that it won’t happen. He may have even subsidized Saddam to kill those clones before the invasion.

  • Bryan says:

    If he was speaking rhetorically, does it follow that he thought Nelson Mandela literally dead?

  • Manfred says:

    He must have. It sounds like one of those off-the-cuff remarks that his handlers live in mortal fear of.

  • Bryan says:

    It seems that by marking it as rhetorical speech that you must necessarily leave the door open for the idea that Bush did not think Nelson Mandela literally dead.
    But now you add that it “sounds like” a gaffe. Can you be more specific?

  • Manfred says:

    Someone from the crowd asked, “Where’s Mandela?”
    The President then replied that he–and his clones–were dead, killed by Saddam. Sounds like one of the reasons Bush is rarely put in front of a live audience to me.

  • Bryan says:

    Manfred, what makes you think the president heard someone in the crowd ask about Mandela?
    I don’t see that in the story you linked. Please don’t tell me that you’re looking into the background, now. ;)

  • Manfred says:

    The President did remark, “I heard somebody say, ‘Where’s Mandela?’”
    I simply drew an inference that he heard a comment from the crowd. Maybe not, but he heard it somewhere.
    What is your explanation of the incident, Bryan?

  • Bryan says:

    It will mean so much more to you if you figure it out on your own, Manfred.

    There is local reconciliation taking place. I had a fascinating conversation in the Roosevelt Room earlier this week with members of provincial reconstruction teams from around Iraq who talked about how people are sick and tired of murder and violence, and that they expect their local governments and their central government to be more responsive to their needs, and local governments are beginning to respond.

    Part of the reason why there is not this instant democracy in Iraq is because people are still recovering from Saddam Hussein’s brutal rule. I thought an interesting comment was made when somebody said to me, I heard somebody say, where’s Mandela? Well, Mandela is dead, because Saddam Hussein killed all the Mandelas.
    http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2007/09/20070920-2.html

    Still think he heard it from the crowd? Follow the link and you can watch the press conference with audio. I didn’t hear anything like that from the crowd–maybe you’ll have better luck.

    Hint:
    http://www.politico.com/blogs/thecrypt/0907/Crocker_No_Nelson_Mandela_in_Iraq.html

  • Bryan says:

    Well, I suppose the commentary section is filtered to protect against spam or something. Unless I’ve been banned for normal conversation. :)

  • Bryan says:

    Not as easy to let you figure it out on your own without using URLs, but I’ll give it a try.

    http://www. whitehouse. gov/news/releases/2007/09/20070920-2. html

    September 11, 2007
    Read More: Iraq

    Crocker: No Nelson Mandela in Iraq

  • Manfred says:

    As you see, I recovered your original comment from the spam bin. Don’t know why it ended up there; only ads for drugs, porn, etc. are supposed to be filtered, not political stuff. I’ll have my Tech VP get on it right away.
    No time to examine it now, as I have to leave for work. Check back later.

  • Bryan says:

    Thanks for rummaging around in there to rescue the original. :)

  • Tony says:

    I really wish I knew where Bush got this stuff, but it makes you wonder if it is a clever ploy. Noone can mess up this much accidentally could they?

  • Manfred says:

    I knew he heard that line somewhere, Bryan–although I didn’t realize he’d stolen it from Crocker. Funny, huh? It would seem that Bush took the Ambassador’s figurative comment literally.
    On second thought, it’s not so funny, since the Iraqis have been “at each others throats” long before Saddam, and continue to be now that he’s gone. It only says that brutality–or force– is all that will work. I don’t think its a very positive outlook for the near future.

  • Bryan says:

    Why does it “seem that Bush too the [a]mbassador’s figurative comment literally” in your opinion?
    What is the specific evidence that you used in drawing that conclusion? The same kind of evidence that led you to conclude that somebody from the crowd asked “Where’s Mandela?”

  • Manfred says:

    If you have another opinion, you’ll have to give it to me; I’m obviously too thickheaded to comprehend where you are going with this, and I don’t like riddles.
    Do you expect me to believe that Bush is some kind of political genius, throwing off brilliancies that only those who agree with his POV understand, but which all of us should take to heart? If so, say it plainly. If not, tell me what you ARE getting at.

  • Bryan says:

    You were able to answer why you thought Bush was fielding a question from the crowd, so why is this question (What is the specific evidence that you used in drawing that conclusion?) any tougher?

    Take your ease, Manfred. I’ll be back later to explain it to you point by point.

  • Manfred says:

    Very well, you tell me what specific evidence you used to draw your conclusion, and what that conclusion might be. I’m all ears.

  • Bryan says:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S1KGwQ1O88Y

    That’s the link to YouTube video of Bush saying the words in question. You may want to refer to it as I make my case.

    1) You’ve already seen the evidence that Mandela was used by Crocker to symbolically compare to the lack of effective unifying leadership in Iraq. Not only did Crocker make a statement along those lines, but so did Condoleezza Rice.
    http://www.usembassy.org.uk/iraq841.html

    2. As I’ve pointed out, Bush specifically referred to a conversation in the Roosevelt Room before he referred to somebody’s “interesting comment.”

    3. Is the following an interesting comment:
    “Where’s Mandela?”
    ?

    4. Now, you can just use the conclusion you’re trying to reach (Bush is stupid) to assume that Bush thinks that “Where’s Mandela?” is an interesting question in the context of Iraqi reconstruction and reconciliation, but if you’re trying to work from the evidence to reach the conclusion instead of using the conclusion to interpret the evidence I wouldn’t recommend it.

    5. It is overwhelmingly likely that Bush thought the issue of Mandela interesting because of the figurative application to contemporary Iraqi politics. See point #6.

    6. Bush probably was referring to more than “Where’s Mandela?” as the “interesting comment.” He was probably quoting/paraphrasing the full exchange he heard in the Roosevelt Room. Watch the YouTube account and listen to the intonation. Bush sustains a different delivery right up through the part about Hussein killing all the Mandelas.

    7. Following from point #6, Bush did not say anything about Mandela himself. He quoted what somebody else said about Mandela. Even if you wish to suppose that the original speaker though Mandela literally dead (a stretch in itself), there’s no evidence at all that Bush agreed with that proposition.

    * I hate to admit it, but intellectual honesty compels me to note that Bush’s comments yesterday about Mandela being “dead,” really were misconstrued.
    http://www.thecarpetbaggerreport.com/archives/12962.html

    Here’s the account from Dana Milbank (WaPo reporter who actually attends the press conferences):
    http://www.registerguard.com/news/2007/09/21/a3.nat.mandela.0921.p1.php?section=nation_world

  • Bryan says:

    I think I’ve offended your filtration system again.

  • Manfred says:

    I must apologize, I suppose, for being taken in by a perfectly respectable news outlet.
    I do not think Bush is stupid, I think he is misguided. And he does have a habit–no offense–of making miscues on camera.

  • Bryan says:

    No offense taken. Bush should not be mistaken for a composed extemporaneous speaker. But the media should be more careful
    Reuters ran the original story, by the way, and they’re doing quite a bit of damage to their reputation lately (same organization that gave us Photoshopped photos from Lebanon about a year ago).

Shortcuts & Links

Search

Latest Posts

SEO Powered by Platinum SEO from Techblissonline